Alfie Kohn and John Taylor Gotto:
John Gotto, is actually spelled, John G”a”tto. It’s an “a” not an “o”. First of all, John Gatto is a former NYC teacher of the year winner, and then he retired that year and went to Carnegie Hall and began to make a career of school bashing. I wrote about him in my book, and after hearing him speak this weekend, I had a chance to speak w/ him and give him a copy w/ my book. And…I told him:
“By the way…I spelled your name wrong in my book. Sorry ’bout that.”
To which he replied:
“That’s all right…i’ll read it tonight and make the appropriate edits.”
Nice guy…He began his speach by giving praise to school drop-outs, especially in the 3 industries in America that people spend the most money on, computers, fast food, and entertainment. You get Bill Gates, Ray Kroc, Dave Thomas, the chick in the Indy 500…point being, many people realize that school does not allow individuals to develop some of their unique creativities.
He blended in a lot of economics and politics into his talk…which I won’t do any justice to here. But…he made it clear how our corporate capitalistic society is only able to survive through the predictability of its consumers. “When every store shelves purple shirts in the spring, they know exactly what they’re doing.” Schooling cannot encourage questioning the status quo, or our economy would collapse. Well…i sort of disagree, because even when we know things like McDonald’s burgers are just well-cooked pieces of shit-infested meat, we still go to eat it. So, blame schools for some things, but not for all.
Alfie Kohn talked about the need to free students from not just tests and grades, but from praise. “When you tell a kid good job, they come to do things w/ an eye always towards the praise.” His philosophy was for teachers to stop controlling students, but to still maintain some structure to ensure they develop intellectually and morally. What was interesting was a comment by a Sudbury teacher, which is a school w/ essentially 0 structure, who found Kohn offensive for suggesting that adults should bring any curriculum to the table.
Then…today I watched the movie “The Emperor’s Club,” about a strict bording school, very traditional. And after being at a conference of school bashing and hearing various philosophies for “free schools” I have floated back to a “it’s all relative” philosophy. With the right student and attitude, traditional schooling can be alright, after all, all us school critics went through that system and are now somewhat functioning adults. Then there was a speaker who said they wouldn’t allow their child to go to school unless they argued a strong case for it. “Anything they want to learn and accomplish they can and more if they only stay out of school.”
A lot to digest…
Crimethink – Good book…I’ve basically embraced pieces of “anarchist philosophy” as they call it, such as living like a bum, trying to pursue the ideal life (last year), sleeping on couches, scamming businesses occassionally, idealist philosophy, plagiarism, not working. But…Crimethink has a bias towards a certain lifestyle over others, which naturally opposes anarchy philosophy, but at least they acknowledge their own hypocracies. They have a nostalgic view of community and living, so walking on the beach and listening to the waves is real living, but watching tv is fake living. Bullshit to me, I say. Just watch the new Andy Milonakis show on MTV, laugh your ass off, and tell me watching a kid throw bags w/ goldfish into a lake in order to “set them free” isn’t the dumbest/funniest shit ever, and every bit as alive as a stroll on the beach.
The other part of Crimethink philosophy I dislike is the idea that we must always be living solely for now. Every second of our lives must be fulfilling our every bliss. First of all…this is impossible, even fantasy land would become boring and mundane at times. With this in mind, it’s no longer worth arguing against doing work that isn’t soul fulfilling, because life is full of ups-and-downs regardless, and if you want certain things, you work. They talk about “selling your time,” but the truth is, is that every second of your life is being spent. If you spend it relaxing at the beach, that’s good but it costs you the days wages you could have made for spending it doing something less idealistic but still possibly rewarding at a job.
If I lived 60 good years…but my 61st was miserable, it would be hard to leave this world w/ a smile. So, it’s important to live for today with a willingness to sacrafice for the future. And while I agree that pleasure can be found in a life w/out money, as the book points out, “it’s awfully hard to live outside the maintstream when everyone you know is living w/in it.” I’d rather work less (ok…i’m unemployed, but this is a general principle) and not go out for meals ever because any prepared meal costs at least 10x what the food costs, but, if I want to meet up with people I need to make those concessions.
reading my first poem – so there was a talent show at the conference…and this guy sitting next to me gets up and does a “spontaneous performance” running and dancing on stage, and reciting a poem, that I later learned, was “spontaneously performed.” It was truly something to observe, not only did he get half the audience up on stage to dance and move with him, but it was a perfect example of creating life out of the sterility of everyday being.
Anyways…this inspired me, because I”ve done my own spontaneous performances many times, only never in front of people. So…I grabbed my book which contained a poem about schooling that was perfect for the moment. Without my usual shaking, and pre-thought hesitations, I got up on stage, announced myself and my general stage fright, and went ahead and read (I’m too lazy to dig it up). It was so easy, really…and I hope to try out some poetry in NYC soon, to see if this is something I can really make a part of my life.
xanga just kicked me off in the middle of a good post…damn. had some good stuff for you…but you’ll live 